Nick Offerman is damn near inseparable from Ron Swanson.
Like Nick, Ron does not benefit from a lack of facial hair. In fact, an increase in facial hair is directly proportional to an increase in overall badassness.
The unfortunate thing about being the actor behind such unmistakable characters is that you’ll never be mistaken for anything else. Including yourself. Including the new character you’re trying to play in a completely different movie set in a completely different world. What gave you a career can just as soon drain it away.
It takes a couple minutes and a glorious salt-and-pepper beard, but there’s enough in Frank Fisher (Offerman) to differentiate him from Ron Swanson. He’s softer. He’s at ease. He’s not so anti-government. Whereas Swanson had a love affair with breakfast foods, wood, and the great outdoors, Fisher finds refuge in the intersection of music and sweet, sweet vinyl. His record shop has the appearance of someone who only cares about the music. Not the colors. Not the graphic design in labels. Not the need for profit to keep the place afloat.
In fact, director Brett Haley and his co-writer Marc Basch do an excellent job of setting up Nick in his first scene, when he argues with a young millennial about records and whether or not he’s allowed to smoke in his own store.
But something connects Frank Fisher and Ron Swanson beyond the their homes on streaming platforms: they’re loathe to change.
For 6 glorious, pun-soaked, big-hearted seasons, Swanson’s antagonists ranged from his own office-mate, Leslie Knope (Amy Poehler), who represented everything he hated (namely government and publicly celebrating birthdays), to Ron Dunn (Sam Elliot), who TRULY represented everything he hated (hippies, veganism, etc).
But from the very beginning, Swanson’s biggest antagonist was change. He did not want to bend to anything. He wanted everything to bend to him. Or better yet, simply pass him by. After 2 failed marriages to two different Tammy’s, it took a woman like Diane and her two darling daughters to break him out of his ways. It was a long journey, but eventually Ron got to a point where he realized he could still uphold his values and make a few tweaks to make room for others.
Heart Beats Loud lays it’s premise out quickly: that Frank, recognizing he can no longer afford his precious record store, will not renew the lease with his landlord. Additionally, he’s only got a summer left with his daughter, Sam (Kiersey Clemons), before she heads off to UCLA.
A fortuitous jam session with Sam leads to a song that catches fire on Spotify, and you can slowly see Frank start to recognize that maybe he CAN have it all: maybe he can date his landlord, who will help him keep his shop open, and maybe even the song will convince his daughter to stay in Jersey so they can develop their band and do the music thing. He can have all the things he wants and is danger of losing: a successful store, a viable partner, a band, and a creatively and emotionally fruitful relationship with his talented daughter.
But to have all those things would require others to give up what they want. To make sacrifices that may benefit Frank in the short-term. But that in the long term? Everyone loses. And Frank knows this.
Offerman’s always had an incredible expressive face – 6 seasons of Ron Swanson taught me just how many emotions he can elicit with only his eyes and eyebrows, the rest of his face dominated by a glorious mustache – but his eyes become even redder and wearier and sadder as he realizes everything is shrinking away from him.
Everyone is moving on and changing but him. His daughter has the future ahead of her across the country in Los Angeles. His landlord is dating someone else. His best friend, Dave (Ted Danson), is enjoying his foray into the world of marijuana. Everyone’s chasing their happiness. And yet his seems more unattainable than ever.
Part of the beauty of well-told stories is how they guide their story into a corner seemingly impossible to get out from, and they somehow pull the damn escape off. Haley and Basch find a way to deftly wrap up their story with the bright shine of future potential and yet remain emotionally true to their characters. It is satisfying and rich, like the kind of record Frank would appreciate: a rare and unexpected find in a low-key, but lovingly-owned store.